BLIND GOSSIP

The #1 Blind Item Site in the World!

Athlete And Coffee

[Blind Gossip] Whenever this famous athlete is struggling in his relationships, we have to roll our eyes.

He is so intent on keeping a “good guy” narrative going that he has to invent multiple levels of lies to cover up his bad behavior.

His current situation reminded us of a secret relationship that he had years ago with a famous female celebrity.

Want to hear about it?

Of course you do!

At the time of our story, Athlete was dating a woman from a wealthy family. As Athlete is very fitness conscience, it will not surprise you that he met her at the gym.

We’ll call her Blondie.

Athlete was not faithful to Blondie.

The other woman?

She was a gorgeous model.

She had recently started acting, primarily overseas. We’ll call her Coffee.

Athlete was introduced to Coffee while he was on a road trip. He became instantly infatuated with her.

It was a whirlwind romance out of the public eye.

Athlete flew back and forth between the two women. Neither of them knew about the other.

After just a few months, Athlete proposed to Coffee.

Coffee said yes!

He told her to keep it quiet but she was so excited about her engagement to this famous American athlete that she told some of her friends in the entertainment industry.

Word got back to Athlete – who was still dating Blondie – that Coffee was blabbing about their engagement.

A panicked Athlete told his publicists to shut down the rumor.

They claimed that not only was Athlete not engaged to Coffee… he had never even met her!

Ouch.

Furthermore, they said that he was was actually in a relationship with Blondie… and that he was going to marry Blondie!

Needless to say, Coffee was shocked and devastated.

What happened to everyone in this story?

Well, Athlete did go on to marry Blondie soon after this happened.

They had a family. However, Athlete cheated on Blondie and their marriage eventually ended in divorce.

Athlete is currently in a messy relationship with a celebrity who will probably be mad that she isn’t the star of this story. Their relationship is fraught with the same kinds of lies that he has been telling for decades. If he is accused of cheating on her with another woman, he claims that he never even met the other woman.

He hasn’t changed.

Coffee went on to have a successful acting career. In fact, a few years after her breakup with Athlete, she went on to become one of the stars of a very popular long-running TV comedy series.

Coffee is now married to a handsome actor. She is still gorgeous and, thanks to her star turn in that TV series, is now very rich and very famous. It’s a modern success story!

She is happy.

To this day, the relationship between Athlete and Coffee is not mentioned anywhere. When they do run into each other, they are very civil but do not talk about their previous relationship. It’s easier just to pretend that it was just a rumor at the time. Coffee does not feel the need to relive the humiliation and Athlete needs to maintain his myriad of lies. 

But now you know that Athlete once secretly asked Coffee to marry him!

Similar: Hide The Weapons

Athlete:

Blondie:

Coffee:

[Optional] What will happen to Athlete in his current relationship?

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Delightful says

    A-rod and Sofia Vergara. His first wife was a rich blonde he met at the gym. That is a weird thing to do, propose to 2 people at the same time, and Alex sounds really fucked up and Jennifer Lopez can do a lot better than him, this is embarrassing now. She def has a type- embarrassing men that are not good enough for her. As for Sofia Vergara- I hope she is planning a Hollywood tell all when she is 80 because she seems to find herself in the oddest situations, yet stays discreet and likable

  2. aaaBunni says

    Sofia Vergara and A-Rod would have made beautiful babies if they’d have gotten married.

  3. kvetro60 says

    ARod. Blondie is his ex-wife who comes from prominent Miami family. Coffee is Sofia Vegara who was a model in Columbia where she is from. She moved with her son to Miami and I imagine that’s where she met him. She’s made tons of $$ from Modern Family and endorsements and married to handsome actor Joe Manganiello.

  4. Sophiema says

    I’ve never heard about them dating before but this must be:

    Athlete: AROD

    Blondie: his ex wife Cynthia Scurtis

    Coffee: SOFIA VERGARA – OMG

    [Optional] What will happen to Athlete in his current relationship? well, this river will definely run its course

    • NoseyNana2008 says

      Man, Ms Vergara dodged a bullet, but just look at her now! I think she and Joe Manganiello look good together.

  5. xomollypops14ox says

    Athlete: A-Rod
    Blonde: Ex wife Cynthia
    Coffee: Sofia Vergara (Colombian, famous coffee country)

    Optional: Jlo needs to find a new ex fiancé

  6. jon117 says

    Holy s*!!!
    Coffee is definitely Sofia Vergara and athlete is definitely Alex Rodriguez. Poor Jennifer

  8. grrrsuperlauren says

    Wow! Alex Rodriguez and coffee is Sofia Vergara. He married Cynthia Scurtis.

  10. lisaNJ says

    Athlete: Alex Rodriguez (ARod)

    Blondie: Cynthia Scurtis, his first wife

    Coffee: Sofia Vergara from Modern Family, also does Ninja coffee commercials

    What will happen to Athlete in his current relationship? Two sayings come to mind: “Once a cheater, always a cheater” and “When a man marries his mistress, he creates a job opening”…even if he reconciles with JLo and they get married, or if he marries the latest sidepiece, he will continue to cheat because that’s what he does.

  18. Lola53 says

    A-Rod
    Cynthia Scurtis- who met A-Rod in a gym on a Stairmaster
    Sofia Vergara! Clue was ‘modern’ success story.. But that is so hard to believe.. I mean J-Lo is no saint either.. But what do these mega hot women see in a piece of walking public toilet seat??? Even after hundreds of sterilization, he must be a hazard for various STDs.,.

  19. gummybears says

    Alex Rodriguez

    Blondie Cynthia Scurtis

    Sofia Vergara

    Once a cheater, always a cheater.

  20. vogliodipiu says

    Sofia Vergara and dreadful Alex Rodriguez! He is such a slime ball. What a stab in the back/heart!!

  22. isleparadise says

    Athlete – Alex Rodriguez
    Blondie – ex wife Cynthia Scurtis
    Coffee – Sofia Vergara
    Jlo deserves him

  23. webb1989 says

    Athlete: A-Rod

    Blondie = ex-wife Cynthia Scurtis

    Coffee = Sofia Vergara

    Optional … Athlete is going to get dumped by J-Lo eventually. Even if they scrape by this “situation” – there’s always bound to be more! Always .. .

  24. gossipgirl28 says

    ARod/Cynthia/Sofia Vergara

    JLo being the one who’s mad this isn’t about her lol. I think they are done but don’t want to admit it yet.

  26. JacksHood says

    If A Rod’s ex-wife comes from a wealth family – this all fits.

    A-Rod
    A-Rod’s ex wife Cynthia
    Sofia Vergara

    He and JLO will eventually split. Then she’ll move on to the next guy the next day.

  27. julietjas says

    Alex Rodriguez — baseball on the mug
    Cynthia Scurtis, blond ex wife, they met at a gym
    Sofia Vergara, “modern,” model, highest paid TV actress, now married
    (Messy relationship with a celebrity is Jennifer Lopez, of course.)

  31. Shalaka I says

    This is obviously A Rod. Don’t know who the women are though? Cameron Diaz as blonde?

  34. ImJustHereSoIWontGetFined says

    Athlete: ARod

    Blondie: His ex-wife

    Coffee: Sofia Vergara

    I’m mad at myself for how long it took me to get this. Bonus: He and JLo will never get married.

  36. amagod121 says

    ARod
    Cynthia Scurtis
    No clue

    Optional: It looks like A-Rod and JLo will continue on as they are for as long as they can milk the publicity.

  37. lcinva says

    Obviously ARod – blondie being his ex-wife (Cynthia something?) and model…Sofia Vergara?

  40. kelno19 says

    A-Rod, Cynthia Scurtis, Sofia Vargara. J-Lo will wake up and move on, but not after milking this for all the publicity she can

  41. Michelle says

    AROD. ex wife Cynthia is the granddaughter of a wealthy minister.

    Coffee is Sofia Vergara. Clue is “modern”

  42. mbscott24 says

    Athlete – ARod
    Coffee – Halle Berry (according to the attached blind item)
    Blondie – Cynthia Scurtis
    Wishes it was about her: JLo, she’s desperate, hanging on and in denial. Don’t think it will last!

  47. mountaingirl82 says

    Sofia Vergara is the actress. Modern= modern family. Coffee= the coffee station she does ads for. Idk the others

  48. omgimbackagain says

    Cheater: Alex Rodriguez

    His ex-wife, Blondie: Cynthia Scurtis Rodriguez

    Actress, Coffee: (Colombian) Sofia Vergara

  55. jamiedc78 says

    ARod

    Ex-wife who is from a “prominent Florida family”

    Sofia Vergara

    They JRod will milk it as long as they can before “amicably breaking up”

  57. moonshy says

    Athlete: A Rod

    Blondie: Cynthia, his ex wife

    Coffee: Sofia Vergara

    No way will his relationship with J-Lo last.

  58. LilOne says

    Athlete: ARod (messy, cheater)
    Blondie: ex wife Cynthia (wealthy fam, met at gym)
    Coffee: Sofia Vergara (Colombian=coffee, modern success=Modern Family)

    They are not making it down the aisle! The kids crying made her stay for a while longer but relationship is dunzo!

  59. ticktocktheclock says

    A Rod

    Cynthia Scurtis

    Sofia Vergara

    Current relationship – will eventually split.

  60. Marina says

    A-Rod and Synthia Scurtis, not sure about Coffee. He and JLo will eventually break up.

  61. shan118 says

    Athlete: A- Rod
    Blondie: His ex-wife, Cynthia (who he met in a gym)
    Coffee: Sofia Vergara

    Him and J-Lo will end at some point, they seem intent to drag it out for as long as possible.

  62. LeelooDallas1 says

    (Colombian)Coffee: Sofia Vergara (modern also being a clue)

    Athlete: Arod and X -wife Cynthia

    After Arod and her gross Ex Nick Loeb, I’m even happier she found Joe.

  65. kimba61 says

    Alex Rodriguez
    Cynthia Scurtis
    Sophia Vergara

    The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior. He has clearly established a past pattern.

  66. montebell says

    Fitness conscious ARod. This will sputter out when she’s good and ready. Maybe around the release of a movie or some other type of promotion.

  68. phoenix8209 says

    Athlete: Alex Rodriguez

    Blondie: Cynthia Scurtis

    Coffee: Sofia Vergara (clues “modern” Modern Family; “Coffee” reference to her Colombian heritage?)

  70. JoshuaTree says

    Alex Rodriguez

    Cynthia Scurtis

    Sofia Vergara (def. trade up to Joe Mangianello!)

    “modern” success = modern family
    A-Rod claiming he never met Madison LeCroy despite affair rumors