BLIND GOSSIP

The #1 Blind Item Site in the World!

Wrap Up This Baby Mystery

[Blind Gossip] While the father of this actress’ baby is a mystery to the public, we can give you some clues about his identity!

She did not use some anonymous sperm donor. She asked a friend if he would “donate” his sperm, and he agreed. They are not dating. He will have no legal responsibility for the baby.

One more piece of information: He is someone with whom she worked in the past!

Similar: The Mystery Baby

Actress:

Baby Daddy:

[Optional] If you were ready to have a baby but had no partner, would you go the anonymous donor route or ask a friend to help out?

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Blkgoddess says

    Mindy Kaling.

    I seriously considered going to a sperm clinic for an anonymous donor when I was younger and getting tired of the dating grind. Too many knuckleheads. I was just going to have my own baby on my own terms and raise him/her on my own terms. But then I met my husband and we had a son, so. But if we ever broke up or if hubs dies before we have another child I’d consider the anonymous sperm donor again, for sure.

  4. floopytoopy says

    January Jones & Jason Sudeikis

    Probably the anonymous donor route. But i would’nt want to have a child with no dad, or father figure. I would feel selfish.

  5. GretaGuesses says

    Mindy Kaling

    Rumor has it that her co-star from The Office, BJ Novak is the father. That might just be wishful thinking though.

    I might go with an anonymous donor just to avoid any weird vibes with the friend, or with families or other friends.

  10. melrose71 says

    I’m guessing Mindy Kaling with the donor being her old Office costar B.J. Novak with whom she’s close. They were hilarious together on The Office by the way.

  14. gingersnaps says

    I just saw that Mindy Kaling just had a baby girl? Maybe the dad is a former Office costar? Or maybe someone from The Mindy Project?

  15. MinnieMe says

    Mindy Kaling
    BJ Novak
    Don’t think I would have a baby without a partner to help raise it It’s hard enough to do it as a married couple.

  17. SusieBoo says

    This is going to be Mindy Kaling (my personal #goals) and BJ Novak. They used to date and are still very close friends. I bet it’s his sperm.

  21. leebie78 says

    Mindy Kaling and of course I want BJ Novak to be the daddy, but that seems too obvious. Not sure who else it is though…

  25. amesr09 says

    Mindy Kaling and I think the friend she asked is B.J. Novak. They have this interesting relationship. I think I would go to a friend I Trusted well…

  29. blackmountainbones says

    definitely mindy kaling and and baby daddy has to be bj novak… also the mindy project just “wrapped”

  32. Bubbiek says

    Mindy Kaling and BJ Novak is my guess. They used to date, are good friends and worked together on the Office

  33. rorythedragon says

    In a perfect world this would be Mindy Kaling and B.J. Novak.

    And, yes, I’d go to a friend because I love my friends and our children would be outstanding.

  44. Goodgrief says

    Mindy Kaling and I would do anonymous, friendships are broken and then you are stuck having to share your baby if they want that, with someone you are not on good terms with.

  50. nylahou says

    Actress: Mindy Kaling
    Baby Daddy: BJ Novak

    Didn’t Mindy want to marry BJ at one point? And he didn’t? If so, I hope I’m not right because she’ll be tied to him for the rest of her life!

  51. INeedAVacation says

    Mindy Kaling and BJ Novak??

    I don’t know if I believe this…she said something along the lines of the baby being a pleasant surprise, leading to believe that it was an accident.

  55. celebiddy says

    Mindy kaling
    Idk chris pine?

    Seems like a bad idea. The guy might change his mind about being involved once the reality hits him that he has a biological child. He probably already signed his rights away before the ivf procedure (unless they banged) but it could still strain their friendship eventually. Thinking of 90210 reboot with teddy and silver. Either way i think it’s wrong to purposely bring a child into the world with only 1 parent.Children deserve both.

  58. KCeagle says

    January Jones

    I want to say Jason Sudeikis – but did she work with him in the past or just date?

    Jon Hamm ?

    I’d ask a friend. A friend indeed is one with weed, or exceptional seed. lol.

  68. aaaSeeK says

    I see absolutely no circumstances under which I would have a baby with a “friend.” It’s either going to be an anonymous donor, or I’d adopt.

  87. KrazyCatLady says

    Mindy Kaling
    BJ Novak or the hot dude from her show.
    It would be awesome if it were Brian Barmgartner or Rainn Wilson
    Or Creed Bratton

    • heartcouture says

      Rainn and Creed where babes when they were younger so props to Mindy if so, but I still guess BJ as the baby daddy.

  89. gonegirl81 says

    January Jones? Her little boy doesn’t look much like her … can’t work out who he looks like tho.

    I would prefer to ask a friend than go the anonymous route.

  93. CanaryCry says

    Too many possibilities to list … LOL

    When I was younger, I contemplated that move. Changed my mind later, thankfully.

  95. amyinkamloops says

    Actress: January Jones

    Baby Daddy: James McAvoy

    [Optional] If you were ready to have a baby but had no partner, would you go the anonymous donor route or ask a friend to help out?

    Anonymous

    • Seeing40 says

      The father of January Jones’ kid is Matthew Vaughn, Claudia Schiffer’s husband. That’s why they’ve stayed anonymous.

  98. surfsunsand says

    Actress: Mindy Kaling

    Baby Daddy: BJ Novak

    [Optional] If you were ready to have a baby but had no partner, would you go the anonymous donor route or ask a friend to help out? Sure. Women are considered “advanced maternal age” at 36+ in the gynecological world…if you have the means and the desire to have kids, why not?

    • surfsunsand says

      Oops. Didn’t read the optional part correctly! I would probably go anonymous donor so as to not complicate things with my friend.