[BuzzFoto] Which B/C list singer/musician who writes her own songs, recently came to the conclusion that because she has never really experienced a healthy relationship with a man, she might actually be gay? She’s always had really close women friends who she bonds well with, but her relationships with men always seem to go south and she’s never really felt she’s been in love before. She’s decided to explore this new part of herself and we’ll see if any new relationships pop up in the news. 712
Kelly Clarkson
Is she B/C list? I would have thought closer to A/B, but maybe I’m grading on a curve.
But wait, I thought all gays were “born that way.” (eye roll)
jjonesy, i agree with you. Kelly is more A/B. And no one here better even think about suggesting Taylor Swift. She is definitely A-list. ;/
or maybe she always was and just realized it, a lot of people do later in life (eye roll)
true; and this is the cause of some divorces although for some people it’s easier to just blame it on a midlife crisis than acknowledge they truly were born this way.
Yes, and a lot of people who are born that way are shamed into hiding it by bigots and homophobes.
And some people just realize later in life.
PS – You should check out Kinsey’s research.
Yup, people are “born that way”. That’s probably why she’s never had a healthy / true love relationship with a man. Way to be both close-minded and demeaning in only one sentence.
Er, having a relationship with your own sex or gender doesn’t make you gay, necessarily.
Much love, a bisexual.
^This, too. Very salient point.
This ^
*Fun Fact* one of Kelly’s biggest hits “Miss Independent” was actually written by Christina Aguilera, it was a track that didn’t make it onto “Stripped” in the end, and it later wound up with Kelly who finished it and put it on her album
you can still find Christina’s name in the credits
I personally think Kelly is at the least bi, but she’ll always be A List to me!
How is that a fun fact – alot of people write for other people. One of Kelly’s songs from her last album was written by Katy Perry. And the gal who used to write with Pink on all of her stuff wrote “I am Beautiful” for Christina. And on and on and on….and of course you can find song writer’s names in the credits – its where they belong.
because Kelly was being thrown out as a popular guess for this, and Christina wasn’t, because a lot of people don’t know Christina is also a songwriter. that’s why I said “fun fact”.
and no, Linda did not write Beautiful for Christina, she wrote it for herSELF. Everyone wanted that song, but she didn’t want to give it away. that is until she heard Christina sing it.
Kelly Clarkson is an A. Period.
Taylor swift…. :S
I think Taylor Swift is considered A-list…
Yea right. Taylor is A list. She took home two Grammy’s just last week, had a sell-out tour last year and was named entertainer of the year. Anyone guessing her must be living under a rock.
She should be F list. Her lyrics are sophomoric, silly and read like diary entries from a 12 year old’s journal. Considering she’s the same age as infinitely more talented Adele really puts that into perspective.
this is a really uncalled for comment. she has ton of fans which include my girlfriend who is considerably older than this demographic. Please keep your own “sophmoric” comments to yourself.
Taylor Swift lol
I want to say Swifty but is she B/C?
Kesha?
That’s an interesting guess.
this was my first guess.
i like this guess. kesha sucks.
Avril Lavigne?
I totally agree, although I’m searching for clues. I remember when her first CD came out, the songs were all apparently written by her, plus the word “pop” in the blind makes me think of the whole argument between Avril and her fans about whether she was a pop singer or a punk singer.
Avril Lavigne
kelly clarkson. first post
She writes her own songs? Does she even still “sing”?
ACK!! Scratch that… I misread it for Kelly Osbourne for some reason. I’m home with a bad cold today.
Sarah McLachlan was my 1st thought and the 2 female figures create an ‘M’ ?! Maybe?
I’d say a marriage/relationship over a decade long isn’t “always going south”.
I like this guess! The “close bonds with women” made me think of Lillith Fair.
I thought Sarah had been out as being bi for awhile. By the way, I can’t hear her name without seeing those sad doggie faces on that commercial.
Id say Rihanna, but she aint no B/C list. Kelly Clarkson.
Taylor Swift?
Taylor Swift?
Taylor Swift?
Sheryl Crowe?
Yes! Best guess so far
Don’t believe Taylor Swift AT ALL. She is a professional beard, so she obviously knows the relationships she gets herself into are gonna fail. And if this isn’t the case, then her gaydar isn’t turned on. I just feel if a girl as young as her has had so many bad relationships, the FIRST thought she has isn’t to switch teams, ya know. She seems too young and naive for that type of thinking. Also, I heard she is still a virgin, so I dunno…
That’s a good guess.
I like this guess. She hasn’t been exactly lucky in love. And Taylor S. would be awfully young to be switching teams due to bad relationships.
Anyway, good luck to Sheryl or whomever this may be. Hope it works out for her.
Sheryl Crow is exactly what I was thinking. She was big long enough ago to be B/C list now. Her relationships with men have been disasterous, and she’s got lots of famous close girl friends, like Jen Aniston.
Sheryl Crow was my first guess but then I remembered she was with Lance Armstrong for quite a while so I changed it to Kelly Clarkson who I’ve often wondered about.
I too first thought of Sheryl Crow right out of the box myself. But she is still “A” in my book – she has to be one of the best selling rock/folk gals of all time.
Kelly Clarkson?
Kelly Clarkson?
Avril Lavigne
Taylor or Miley?
miley has good luck with relationships…she is in a longterm one right now..
I would guess Taylor Swift but she’s definitely A list, so I’m going to go with Kelly Clarkson??
Kelly Clarkson?
Sheryl Crow?
Ditto on the guess.
Cheryl Crow? just a random guess
good one
Sheryl Crow . I think she had a relationship with larry Davids ex-wife
They looked very “CLOSE” when they were on the “Real Time With Bill Maher” a few years ago.
I would kind of love it if this was Taylor Swift.
xtina
thinking genie in the bottle could be the pop up reference
I like this guess.
Xtina doesn’t write her own songs
yeah she does, actually. She writes just as much as Lady Gaga, they “co write” their songs and you’ll find Christina’s name first on almost every single song she’s put out since her “Stripped” album with the exception of a few gems that were handed to her. And not her name with a bunch of others, it’s usually just her and one other person. I’m a huge Linda Perry fan and I know how much Christina has written with Linda.
This isn’t her blind, though, she’s been vocal about her attraction to women since like 2001. Christina has never hid that part about her, ever.
Taylor Swift?
She needs a new PR team to make these relationships happen…
Taylor Swift will probably be a popular guess, but surely she’s higher than B/C…
Kelly Clarkson!
Taylor Swift
New and I love you!
Sheryl Crow!
A funnier answer: Taylor Swift! (though she is obviously A list at this point.)
Ke$ha
Kelly Clarkson?
Sheryl Crow
Is Taylor Swift B/C list?
Kelly Clarkson?
Nooooo Taylor Swift is lesbian?
Taylor Swift is not b/c list.
Taylor Swift
Where does Taylor Swift rank?
Alanis. I’m a huge fan. So it’s not a slight. But she always gave me that girl on girl vibe.
Alanis is married.
nnicole, i swear ive always gotten a vibe from her too. STRONG VIBE. and yes, i know that her first album was completely based on that bad relationship with dave coulier and that she dates ryan reynolds and has a baby now and bla bla bla, but i still think there is something there.
meant to say “dated ryan reynolds”.
Kelly Clarkson. First time poster, long time follower. Love this site. Hi, Ace!
Hi Econ! Love, Ace
Taylor Swift
Kelly Clarkson?
Abril levigne?
T Swift?
Kandi Burruss
Definitely agree 100%!!!
There have been blinds hinting to this before.
Kelly Clarkson?
Pink?
I would consider Taylor Swift to be pretty much A list for how man-years she has dominated the Grammys. She sings and writes all her own music as well as does her own guitar.
*many
Sheryl Crow is my guess.
Sheryl Crow?
Ashley Simpson? She is divorced with a baby but I dont know if “healthy” or “in Love” would describe her relationships – seriously, i do not know. Total guess. Definately B/C list, at best, IMO.
Ashlee…. writing her own songs? BAHAHAHAHAHA. Not in -this- reality!!
I have to hop on board with the Kelly Clarkson guess. She’s the first person I thought of when reading this blind.
I know she is pretty grimm in talent but her bio’s all say singer/songwriter (as well as actress believe it or not) She is closer to a c/d rating i guess. I just cannot see Kelly clarkson as b/c rating. Only thing not jiving with me yet…
she writes many of her songs. Shadow was based on her living in the shadow of her sister, Jessica for example. And she is more C list.
Sheryl Crow?
Taylor Swift
Avril Lavigne
Taylor Swift?
MICHELLE Branch ?
Also Fefe Dobson?
What did we time travel to 2001 when both of those people were relevant? lol
Michelle Branch has been married for almost 8 years.
Pink is a singer, songwriter, and plays several instruments. Is she still in that rocky relationship with her husband?
Yes and they have an eight month old baby. She’s busy being a new mom and trying to get the baby weight off so I doubt it’s her.
Pink is a lot higher than B/C she is probably A minus. Though I’d say solid A.
Kandi from RHATL?
It is not Taylor Swift – Definately A list
It is not Kelly Clarkson – Definately A/B list (she just sang the national anthem at the super bowl).
Avril = B/C
Michelle Branch = C/D
Sheryl Crow = Maybe B/C – I think C/D
Pink; She is married
Kesha= C/D
Demi Lovato, I want to see her make love to Selena Gomez.
lol
The Bieb might dig that too.
Lol xD she’s my guess too.
Alanis Morissette = Married
Here are other Singer / Songwriters:
Sara Bareilles
Amy Lee (Evanesence)
Lisa Loeb
Stevie Nicks
Katy Perry – A List
Rihanna – A List
Amy Lee’s married and I think Lisa Loeb is too.
Lisa Loeb is married and she and her husband are expecting their second in the next few months.
Taylor is A or even A+ she won 2 Grammys last week. Not her. I think of Kelly Clarkson. Or Demi Lovato.
+ I think SHE’VE BEEN IN LOVE ALREADY, listent to all Taylor’s albums
Kelly Clarkson. I’d say she’s low B level now – dropped off a bit since her first two albums – and has flat out said she’s never been in love. Relationships never last or go anywhere.
Kelly is definitely higher than B/C list…she has the #1 song in the country right now! Plus she’s not really a “musician” and while she does write some of her own songs she’s not really known for that.
I would go more for someone like Sheryl Crow. The picture makes me thing of her song “Soak Up The Sun”
agree with Minx! Sheryl Crow. That last line reference to “Pop” was gnawing at me and “Have some fun” is it! She has awesome women circle of pals but even she seems higher than b/c rating…the suggestion of “c” list drops talent alot I think – not just recent earning power. IMO
Taylor Swift is gay? Yeah right, I
thought she was just a virgin?! So tired of Taylor Swift gossip, shes SO BORING. I don’t CARE to whom her vag belongs to.
That being said, we have to consider a woman who sings and writes her own songs BUT more importantly PLAYS INSTRUMENTS! When was the last time Katy Perry, a popular answer so far, has touched an instrument that isn’t her breasts? LMAO
Maybe its a country singer, as they usually sing and strum. Not a country fan so I would leave that to someone else.
Hmm, just to be different – what about Joss Stone? Or Colbie Caillat? Does anyone know much about their dating lives?
I think Colbie is about to get married, but I could be confusing her with Sara Bareilles.
Really convinced this is Kelly Clarkson. She has consistently denied being gay, but has also claimed to never been in love. Rumors are that she is dating one of her female managers or backup singers. Who cares though let the girl be happy.
Official guess on this one is definitely Kelly Clarkson.
My guess is Kelly Clarkson. I know I’ve read articles where she’d downplay the les thing by saying she’s had boyfriends, but never admitted to being in love with them or any of them going anywhere. It sounds like her. The B/C list bothers me though.
If not Kelly, the Sheryl Crow. However she seemed to be in love with Lance Armstrong.
Kelly Clarkson, final answer.
the b/c thing bother me too. i think this whole rating famous people is in the eye of the beholder. even if for the most part, we, as the people who log in here to write our guesses, can usually rate famous people better than the people writing these things. that said, kelly is more b/a. sheryl crowe could fit b/c.
This sounds like Kelly Clarkson. I would have thought she would have been considered a B list singer/musician but B/C is close enough.
When you say “musician”, I think of someone who plays an instrument. I didn’t know Kelly played anything but her perfect voice.
What about Vanessa Carleton, Sarah Borelis(spelling?) or KT Tunstall? They are all musician/singer/songwriters.
Katy Perry (WITH Rihanna). Maybe with the divorce, she’s sort of in this limbo wondering “did I ever REALLY love Russell? Have I ever REALLY loved a man? Hmmmm.”
There is no way that Katy is B/C list.
And I can’t stand her, so no bias there.
Chely Wright FTW.
Great guess, however Chely Wright has been out for years…was on Oprah and Ellen talking about it!
Yeah, I know… I was joking. Sorry, should have made it more clear!
Oh, I like the Sheryl Crow guess. I can see how having a relationship with Lance, the doper, would drive a straight woman gay (or a gay man straight).
The doping allegations were just closed by the Feds. He may be an alleged doper, but nothing was proven.
If she wasn’t engaged, I’d say Britney, hahaha. She “writes” her own songs.
Britney is A+ list.
The first one I thought of was Taylor Swift, but she’s definitely not B/C list either. Neither is Ke$ha.
I’m going with Vanessa Carlton.
Colbie Calliet is my second choice.
Mandy Moore is my third choice.
Mandy Moore has been married to Ryan Adams for years quite happily.
I’m going to go Tori Amos on this one.
Do you actually know anything about her or did you guess because of her genre? Not only has she pretty much admitted to being bi, she’s been married since 1998! Not exactly a string of bad relationships.
Love her, she’s married with a child, tho.
Not much good with ratings, it’s all subjective but what about Alicia Keyes for something different?
Be gentle im a noob here!
Ace, i made comments under the grammy no show&tweener &singer items&they didn’t get posted. Did i break a rule/any other reason? Long time lurker New below the line, just want to get along nice! X
No guess, just chiming in to say Kelly Clarkson is A-list-all-the-way-list. No way is she considered anything else. She sang at the Superbowl, hello!
Tori Amos?
Ugh. Married since 1998, pretty much out as bi.
lol nobody reads.
Shakira. Just sayin’. Pretty sure.
It’s not Taylor or Kelly. They are both A list.
Tori Amos, Michelle Branch, and Mandy Moore are married. Avril is back with Brody Jenner.
Taylor Swift is def A list… and I’d say Kelly is in that range as well. Plus, she’d look like an idiot if she was truly exploring her ‘lesbian side’ after being so insulted last month when asked if she is a lesbian. Usually gay celebs distract it a bit like Ricky Martin by refusing to ask the question – not denying it completely.
The best guesses are Sheryl Crow, Vanessa Carlton, and Colbie Caillat… Vanessa apparently said she was bi last year so… so it’s prob her?
Sarah Maclachlan?
Huge lesbian following, she can play for our team anytime!
Alanis Morissette
I’m on board with Sheryl Crow.
Avril Lavigne
Vanessa Carlton has already come out as bisexual so not her (unless this is an old story)
I’d say Sheryl Crow or Stevie Nicks – it’s said that at one point, the two gals were more than buddies.
LOL Stevie Nicks is gross ahahaha! I do like Fleetwood Mac.
Colbie Caillat?
Alanis Morrisette??? i think she has a man and a baby tho..hmmm
I think “go south” is a clue. I think Texas would be considered southern in this blind. Kelly Clarkson is from Texas. I think it’s her.
Yes, I agree. South is def a clue….
Long time fian…first time poster… Paula Cole?
Hi Soph! Love, Ace
Pretty sure this is Colbie Caillat. She’s made jokes about her lack of success in the romance department, writes her own songs, and there has been speculation elsewhere not here that her guitarist may be a beard. On the other hand, she’s also said that she and her guitarist have been quietly together for several years.