CDAN – 
This is just a great story. Earlier this week, two women were having lunch at a place in Toronto when they noticed that a man had sat down. This man, who used to be A+ list back in the day and is still loved by enough people that he is a B list singer and reality star saw them looking at him. They waved and he waved back. This is like their biggest star crush. That would usually be it, but our celebrity, got up from his table, walked over to the two women, sits down and starts chatting with them. He stays and talks to them about his career and answers all of their questions. Then, one of the women asks if she can take his photo and a waiter rushes over and says there is a no photo policy, but our celebrity will have none of that and says of course. He then takes a picture, chats some more and even asks to use one of the stories about him that one of the women shared which he is going to use in his shows. After he left, the restaurant manager came by and said that most celebrities are a-holes but this guy was the greatest and the biggest tipper in a place that gets its share of A list movie stars.
Brett Michaels?
I second Brett Michaels. Meatloaf is not very nice.
I think you’re right! He likes the ladies and the ladies seem to like him! Plus he seems like a very nice guy, from what i’ve seen of him at least!
haha and i don’t think meatloaf is anyone’s biggest celeb crush… unless they mean literally BIG….
Hasselhof ?
I second this guess.
Meat Loaf? He’s doing the Apprentice this year and still has some pretty hardcore fans, and he seems like he’d be really nice.
However, I can’t exactly see many people having a crush on him though.
I would guess David Cassidy before Meatloaf…
I am guessing Cassidy too. He loves Toronto and I have seen him in the city a few times. he was always nice to my female friend who was a fan of his when she was a kid. This was the first guess I had when reading the blind but didn’t know he was on a reality show. Since reading the guesses that he was or is on celebrity apprentice I am going with him for the win.
I like the David Cassidy guess.
Crushed by him, maybe?
Meat lost his weight decades ago. He’s worn fat suits in movies since then. He does a bunch of charity work but I don’t think this is him.
I like this, too!
First time poster! I say this is Nikki Sixx from Motley Crue. He was in Toronto this week. I have heard he is a really nice guy and I can totally see the crush factor. Also he has a radio show sixxsense – that is probably the show he will share the stories.
Donny Osmond? Winner of DWTS and just announced (from Toronto) that he and Marie will be doing shows in Toronto this summer (see link)?
http://arts.nationalpost.com/2011/03/07/donny-and-marie-osmond-coming-to-toronto-with-vegas-show/
If this is him — I *love* this story…Donny was my very first childhood crush in the 70s!!!
Agreed, I think this is Donny Osmond too.
I doubt Brett Michaels or Nikki Sixx have ever been A+ list crushes.
you doubt Bret Michaels or Nikki Sixx have ever been A+ crushes. You’d be wrong. Can’t vouch for Nikki but my friends and I absolutely loved Bret Micheals. My friend had her first kid in 1990 and named him Bret. And I know we weren’t the only ones.
I agree with the Donny Osmond guess. But, now I’ll be aging myself but, back in the day Donnyboy was A-list and all the girls had crushes on him along with lunchboxs and poster over their beds. And you weren’t cool if you didn’t have all of the Teenbeats. But, I don’t recall him ever having I reality show.
Is DWTS considered a reality show? If so, then Donny Osmond it is! I can totally see him doing this. And yes, I had Teenbeat posters taped to the back of my bedroom door….
Steven Tyler or Brett Michaels, they both seem really nice. I had to re-read the description a few times before I could understand it.
I don’t think Bret MIchaels or Nikki Six were ever A+.
Donny Osmond is a good guess–he was a gigantic star back in his time.
NKOTB’s Jordan Knight. He’s been all over local T.O. talk shows promoting his new single and upcoming tour with Backstreet Boys.
Unfortunately, I don’t think he’s got a reputation of being nice, which is sad cuz he was my NKOTB crush.
I’ve met him and he is OK. He wasn’t mean, but he def didn’t seem like the type who would chat up a few super fans. And I am not just saying this cause Joey was my favorite either! Lol.
I don’t think any of these guesses were ever A+, but I don’t have any better guesses.
Steven Tyler was definitely A+ and I would say still is!
I like the Bret Michaels guess… He won me over when he was on Apprentice and he’s still pretty hot. Plus he loved women – all women, in a really good way.
Gene Simmons?
Gene still thinks he’s A-list….lol
Jordan Knight. He’s in Toronto this week doing promo stuff for solo work and upcoming NKOTB tour…and was also on a couple of those celebrity house shows.
Donny Osmond
I’ll say Steven Tyler. He seems like a sweet guy who really would love to sit with his fans. Plus, he’s an old man who likes to talk.lol
And, I LOVE him (had a crush on him since I was 11…and I’m 32 now).
Daryl Hall
Rick Springfield? Why would this be a BI most stars love the positive claims that they are friendly and good tippers?
I’ll go with Cassidy as well.
First person I thought of.
Me too! He was in around Toronto last week
http://www.torontosun.com/entertainment/tv/2011/03/03/17482261.html
I’m on board with the Cassidy guesses as well!
OK – let’s go through it. Its somebody who is obviously in Toronto a bunch. What says Steven Tyler about that? And if Steven Tyler wasn’t on AI right now you wouldn’t even know who he was? This blind isn’t about who is a nice guy. It’s about who is a nice guy and is in Toronto alot and was big a while back and is now sort of ok and was on a reality show. And sings.
Nikki Six? Really?
I’d go with Donny or David – but the reality is I don’t know who the heck is hanging out in Toronto at all.
April Wine?
I vote for Steven Tyler…you cannot call David Cassidy, Meatloaf, or even Bret Michaels B List. I mean…Meatloaf was never A+ list and neither was Bret…Poison was a third rate Bon Jovi (although I love their music)
Vince Neil from Motley Crue. I have heard Nikki Sixx is narcissistic(aren’t they all) and abusive to his girlfriends. Although that doesn’t mean he would be nice to fans adoring him. Vince was on that show Surreal Life.
D.O. was just here promoting a show in july, he kept saying how much he loves toronto and seemed to go out of his way to say it in different ways. Reporters noted how personable he was with everyone.
Having said that, i could believe it’s D.C. as well, but i haven’t heard him fawn over T.O.
No idea who, but whoever he is sounds like a truly decent guy.