89 responses

  1. Spikearoo
    November 6, 2010

    Aniston, FTW!

    • FzFz
      November 6, 2010

      I have a hard time seeing her as anything below A list

      • Maybe
        November 6, 2010

        Yeah I could maybe justify dropping her to B+ with some recent stinkers, but in no context is she a C.

      • Caz1310
        November 6, 2010

        Her movies are C quality :) No serious movie studio doing a A+++ movie looking for a stellar cast would consider poor Jen. She’s stuck in bad rom-com hell.

      • ILoveDlisted
        November 6, 2010

        Jen is NOT A list, her movies are garbage, she can’t act

      • Barry
        November 8, 2010

        she plays the same character in every movie: the put-upon, otherwise successful woman who cannot get/understand/hold a man which is 10% her fault and 90% society and the man.
        she is unwatchable unless “I’ll be there for you” immediately precedes her. and even that is old.

    • galactica
      November 6, 2010

      Aniston has her own production company that why she keep cranking out lame-o romantic comedies.

      • Dont Know For Sure
        November 8, 2010

        She’s the one responsible for those movies? Maybe she’s into masochism too.

      • Voltron 2000
        November 9, 2010

        Cant keep a Maniston was on one of the biggest sitcoms in tv history and is definitely considered A list, her movies may bomb but shes still on a top celeb and hollywood top crop

  2. cassandra
    November 6, 2010

    maria bello? katherine heigl?

  3. hobo77
    November 6, 2010

    Katherine Heigel

    • Gitano
      November 6, 2010

      Heigl is one of the highest paid rom-com stars in the movies these days, love her or hate her. So she’s at least b-list.

  4. Cherise
    November 6, 2010

    I thought of Jennifer Aniston. Others who came to mind were Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt.

    • stinkweed
      November 7, 2010

      SMG just had a baby. She’s probably too tired to sleep with her gorgeous hubby, much less a cast of producers and agents.

  5. tdslf
    November 6, 2010

    Michelle Williams

    • LaLa
      November 6, 2010

      WHAT. ARE YOU KIDDING ME???

  6. tdslf
    November 6, 2010

    Hayden Pantinnere or pantyline.

  7. tdslf
    November 6, 2010

    Debra Messing

    • MalR
      November 6, 2010

      I vote debra too!

  8. tdslf
    November 6, 2010

    Heidi Montag

    • My2Brows
      November 6, 2010

      In her DREAMS has Heidi Montag EVER been A-list

      I agree with Katherine Heigel

  9. cndngrl
    November 6, 2010

    I thought Jen Aniston too. “Plan” could refer to Plan B which is the production company she founded with Brad Pitt.

    No way Heidi Montag was ever close to A list…

    • mush
      November 6, 2010

      she may star in only rom-coms, but no way is she struggling.

      • cndngrl
        November 6, 2010

        hmm.. that’s true. I’ll go with Mischa, then.

  10. Mindy
    November 6, 2010

    Courtney Cox

  11. Heywood Jablowme
    November 6, 2010

    What a coincidence! World famous director, Heywood Jablowme just announced production of his new thriller Adventures in… um… Heywoodland!! With sweeping vistas, shot in multiple locations in and around the Jablowme sound stage… and a queen sized futon, it’s the story of a man, his camcorder and a dream. I’m now auditioning former A- list hottie… serious actresses for the co-starring role. Auditions are at the Jablowme production offices, Apt 3A. Please don’t disturb the neighbors, Mrs. Kupchek in 3B calls the cops. SHE’S A PHILISTINE WHO DOESN’T APPRECIATE ART!!

    I smell Oscar!! He’s in 4A. The man does not bathe. I mean, really, that’s just not right.

    • Happy New Year
      November 6, 2010

      Too funny!

    • newtsgal
      November 6, 2010

      Heywood your my hero….where do I sign up……LOL!

    • JustAGuess
      November 6, 2010

      HWJBM, the problem is I think the answer is Betty White. “A” list from Golden Girls and “C” list because of cameos. Plus, her penchant for sleeping around makes this blind solved. LOL. Have fun with Betty and leave some for me.

  12. Leah
    November 6, 2010

    Lisa Kudrow?

    • Mindy
      November 6, 2010

      I doubt it, she was a virgin until her wedding night. But who knows, maybe she’s making up for lost time.

  13. Phie
    November 6, 2010

    Jessica Alba? I’m not entirely sure if she was considered an A list TV star during Dark Angel.. but she could be considered a C+ movie actress. And with all her *-talking interviews, she is definitely after good movie roles.

    • Hmmm
      November 6, 2010

      Agreed, Alba.

    • BrightStar
      November 6, 2010

      Ah, yeah, I just tried to post a comment with a link to a recent interview (it’s being moderated). She’s a stupid cow.

      • Guesswhat
        November 6, 2010

        I’m on board.

      • Booby Jones
        November 6, 2010

        Her interviews are hilariously bad. She once said in one that she was only going to speak to her child in spanish after it was born and kick anyone out of the room who spoke english around the baby. Nice idea, except for the fact that she doesn’t speak a word of it herself.

  14. Ralphie
    November 6, 2010

    I’m going to go with Sarah Michelle Gellar…think the key here is “good roles again” being that the actress once got decent parts. Plus I’ve never bought Freddie Printz Jr as straight.

    • Ruby
      November 6, 2010

      I like this guess. Her career definitely fits the description in the item, and she has a reputation for being very ambitious and not very nice.

      Also married to a lump.

  15. antiaphrodite
    November 6, 2010

    People may not like Heigl, but she is in no way a C-list actress. More like B-list. I also have a hard time picturing her sleeping around for parts.

  16. WHAATT
    November 6, 2010

    Olivia Wilde? Although Barton’s probably the best guess. Maybe Bilson?

  17. BrightStar
    November 6, 2010

    Jessica Alba – Got her start on Flipper and Dark Angel. I would say that back in 2000-2002 she was “almost A list” for Dark Angel. She got nominated for a bunch of awards for it.

    She has done really crap movies, though, except for (in my opinion) Sin City and um… Sin City.

    And she just did that interview where she said she wants to get better roles: http://www.eonline.com/uberblog/b209710_jessica_alba_going_act_realsies_now.html

    In the same interview she says that “good actors never use the scripts,” which seems like an awesome way to never get hired. I feel like she’ll need to sleep with a LOT of people to get past that quote.

    http://www.celebitchy.com/124884/jessica_alba_good_actors_never_use_the_script_unless_its_amazing_writing/

    • BrightStar
      November 6, 2010

      And when I say nominated for a bunch of awards, I mean random meaningless-other-than-for–popularity awards.

  18. Sweetie Tart Pie
    November 6, 2010

    First time posting!

    The first person that came to mind was Kristen Bell.

    • BlindGossip
      November 6, 2010

      Welcome, Sweetie! Love, BG

    • BrightStar
      November 6, 2010

      Interesting guess, but I wouldn’t say that she was ever almost A-list for Veronica Mars, as much as I ADORED that show.

  19. Melina
    November 6, 2010

    Alyssa Milano

  20. Rach
    November 6, 2010

    Jennifer Garner?

  21. KellyinNY
    November 6, 2010

    I’m surprised no one has said Gretchen Mol.

    • galactica
      November 6, 2010

      Gretchen Mol is currently on Boardwalk Empire on Showtime

      • ILoveDlisted
        November 6, 2010

        LOVE Boardwalk Empire!!!

  22. cooper263
    November 6, 2010

    Everyone in La La Land

  23. Gast84
    November 6, 2010

    Sharon Stone.

    • galactica
      November 6, 2010

      Bingo.

    • shesnotagirl
      November 6, 2010

      i dont think she was ever an almost a tv actress.

  24. anonymous
    November 6, 2010

    I was surprised how much TV work she did, so yeah, it could be. She is involved in four upcoming films, so…maybe her clever plan is working!

  25. loco
    November 6, 2010

    Amanda Bynes

  26. Ruby Red Lips
    November 6, 2010

    Mischa Barton or Hayden Paniettere

    For all those guessing Jessica Alba, she is way above a C list movie star! I mean c’mon!

    • norm
      November 8, 2010

      um, no, she’s c list

  27. anonymous
    November 6, 2010

    Gillian Anderson

    • Celimene
      November 7, 2010

      No. Gillian Anderson is doing a lot of critically acclaimed theatre work in the UK. She started in theatre, and will likely stay there. She does films on occasion but I think her heart in stage work.

  28. loon
    November 6, 2010

    Rachel Bilson

  29. Diva E
    November 6, 2010

    I like the Hayden guess. She was insanley popular on that Heros show a few years ago. Now she only does crappy highschool movies

  30. Marina
    November 6, 2010

    People, when you pick a married actress as your guess – how do you picture her sleeping around on a nightly basis? Please, be realistic …

    • Ralphie
      November 6, 2010

      Because that’s ever stopped any of them before! Ha.

    • Caz1310
      November 7, 2010

      Because so many of them do! They don’t sit at home each night watching the tv news & playing scrabble.

    • Kuvastin
      November 8, 2010

      Maybe her husband knows about it and doesn’t mind/can’t stop her?

  31. Hampton
    November 6, 2010

    Aniston-you are crazy all of you. with her money she could just uy the studio. Mischa was never A-list. Heigel has no money worries and continues to be successful with middle america no matter how much you dislike her. Lisa Kudrow-Friends (money) SMG has Buffy money and doesn’t need to work unless Freddie wants a new Bentley Spur.Bilson maks money being a beard for various boys.Could be pantyhose-who knows if her russian is generous. and miss bell is desperate to ddo veronica mars movie. miser alba needs to support her husband. A list network or cable? of course its Paris Hilton or Tila Tequila.

  32. shesnotagirl
    November 6, 2010

    She was my first thought too.

  33. Hampton
    November 6, 2010

    Aniston-you are crazy all of you. with her money she could just buy the studio. Mischa was never A-list. Heigl has no money worries and continues to be successful with middle America no matter how much you dislike her. Lisa Kudrow-Friends (money) SMG has Buffy money and doesn’t need to work unless Freddie wants a new Bentley Spur.Bilson makes money being a beard for various boys.Could be pantyhose-who knows if her Russian is generous. and miss Bell is desperate to do veronica mars movie. miser Alba needs to support her husband. A list network or cable? of course its Paris Hilton or Tila Tequila.

  34. Ahorsenamedbill
    November 6, 2010

    1st guess is Debra Messing – based on the pic of the blue couch in the pic and her last show which was almost good enough to get renewed… That and I think she’s coke mom – so desperation for the hwood lifestyle & possible need for $
    2nd guess is Sharon Stone based on how many projects she has in production- she’s kinda been over for a while/why soooo many projects??

  35. Ahorsenamedbill
    November 6, 2010

    Forgot to mention Will&Grace hAd a blue couch

  36. hopefulromantic
    November 6, 2010

    I’m going with Aniston. 1) A list television actress, 2) C list movie actress (she hasn’t had a hit since The Break Up), 3) the blue couch is reference to the infamous Friends couch that the opening montage incorporates.

    • Pickle
      November 7, 2010

      Because of the couch reason, I’m now convinced it’s Jennifer Aniston. Good job!

      • insider1970
        November 7, 2010

        I will add that Jennifer Aniston owns along with Brad Pitt and Brad Grey “Plan B” production company, and this is maybe why the word “plan” is used often in the blind.

    • mbm2
      November 7, 2010

      Aniston’s A list TV, B-list movie. she did the round of the casting couch pre-Friends. now Angelina on the other hand…

      my guess: Mischa Barton (The OC was Fox’s top show until she left)

  37. anonymous
    November 7, 2010

    I would be amused if it WAS Aniston. The thought of her * herself around (and she herself being richer than all of us put together) to get “good roles” makes me giggle. Is that how one gets good roles though? Is there a secret stash of good roles secretly locked up by the H’Wood bigwigs that they will release ONLY to those celebs that will put out?

  38. nancy
    November 7, 2010

    jen aniston was not an ‘almost A lister’. more like a solid A lister.

    • I guess
      November 7, 2010

      Yup, this is why I don’t think it’s Jen. Her latest movies may be simple rom-com but they are made cheaply and always break even or better. She has big money. If she really wanted she could be in nothing but “deep” indie movies, she just doesnot care enough.

      • ILoveDlisted
        November 7, 2010

        There are alot of stars with LOTS of money that are NOT A list. Shes prob trying to get that Oscar role, break out of the predictable rom com

  39. Leah
    November 7, 2010

    Blake Lively

  40. Mrs. Darcy
    November 7, 2010

    Mischa Barton or Rachel Bilson

  41. the gun
    November 7, 2010

    Meg ryan or lucy liu!

  42. Cecilia
    November 7, 2010

    Melissa joan heart!!! WTF happened to her????

    • Caz1310
      November 7, 2010

      oh good guess! I’m sure I read something somewhere indicating she’s gone completely off the rails and is desperate to work again…

      • melba
        November 8, 2010

        Please, she is starring on my ultimate guilty pleasure, Melissa and Joey, on ABC Family. Clarissa Explains it All is in a hilarious Who’s the Boss live-in housekeeper/nanny situation with Joey Lawrence. It is every bit as cheesy as any early 90s sit com, and I’m obsessed.

  43. Dont Know For Sure
    November 8, 2010

    Neve Campbell. She could be taking her role in “Wild Things” (I think that’s the movie) too literally.

  44. t.in.d
    November 8, 2010

    Jessica Biel? This is a little bit of a stretch but the A-team’s tagline had “plan” in it and she was in “Powder Blue.”

  45. spooky
    November 8, 2010

    Megan Mullaly or however you spell it

  46. lydiavance
    November 8, 2010

    Misha was also my first though. This is almost certainly her.

Leave a Reply

You must be to post a comment.

Back to top